damnum absque injuria

December 28, 2005

The Battle of Wounded Knee: or Look what Evil Whitey did to the Redskins

Filed under:   by Cardinal Martini @ 1:18 am

In 1889, a Paiute Indian named Jack Wilson decided he was the Messiah and created a new movement called the Ghost Dance Religion. It was based on hating the White Man.** Several of the early converts were from the Sioux Nation. While Sitting Bull, leader of the Sioux, was not one of the Ghost Dancers, he nevertheless tolerated their wacky religion.

This turn of events made the US government nervous, and so some federal agents tried to bring in Sitting Bull on December 15, 1890; a gun battle ensued, and Sitting Bull was killed. The new leader of the Sioux and his followers met up with the 7th Cavalry in Wounded Knee, South Dakota. Apparently, both sides were trying to make peace, and so the Sioux all but surrendered to the Army.

On the morning of Dec. 29, 1890, while the US Army was attempting to disarm the Sioux, a gun evidently went off, chaos ensued, 153 Indians and 25 Cavalrymen were killed. And so it has been called the Battle of Wounded Knee.

Insane Progressives — but I repeat myself — however, apparently can’t view historical events such as this merely as what happened before, and see America for what she is today. Instead, these Progs have to continually dredge up whatever past so-called injustices they can find and beat everyone about the head with them. Mark Anthony Rolo, writing in the Anniston (Alabama) Star, is one such lunatic lefty:

For American Indians, however, that snowy South Dakota morning proved to be one of the most significant days in their history. The deadly events at Wounded Knee brought to an end what was once known as the Indian Wars Period, in which Indian tribes resisted efforts by the U.S. military to force their people into prison-like land parcels in order to clear the way for white settlers.

Today, the massacre at Wounded Knee is mythologized and memorialized as just one of a number of tragic, ugly stories of how this country was formed. But for generations of American Indians, Wounded Knee has meant more than mere history. The massacre has passed down scars of suspicion and badges of bitterness toward the white man.

Question: Why are Progressives so obsessed with race?

Cross-posted at Cardinal Martini (my home blog)

This post has been linked at Diggers Realm’s “Around the Blogosphere #31″.

** In the comments, Clark Smith makes me think I should clarify something. In its original conception, the Ghost Dance Religion may have focused on the glory of Indian culture, rather than solely on “hating the white man”. (Although I have my doubts that it was truly about “pining for their own culture as preceded the arrival of the white man” considering the Ghost Dance doctrine contains a lot of Christian symbolism and themes — most notably that there is only one true God.) So, perhaps I was unfair in suggesting Jack Wilson himself created it merely with the intention of formalizing a hatred of the white man. Nevertheless, it is clear to me based upon what I know of the pertinent events that the Sioux who joined the Religion, and eventually were “massacred” by the Army, did so because they hated whites and believed the Religion accurately predicted a coming destruction of the whites.

5 Responses to “The Battle of Wounded Knee: or Look what Evil Whitey did to the Redskins”

  1. Marty McGowan Says:

    Who says _we_ are obsessed?

    And to your point, history is written by whom? Scars and suspicion abound. They are attached to the latest calumny. Wounded Knee must therefore be the last.

  2. Dave Schuler Says:

    Why? Authenticity. American Indians, Palestinians, sub-Saharan black Africans, etc. are putatively not corrupted by rationalism, Christianity, and the other appurtenances of Western culture and are, consequently, authentic.

  3. clark smith Says:

    I’m not so sure the ghost dance was about “hating the white man” so much as it was about pining for their own culture as preceded the arrival of the white man.

    The ghost dance was about enjoying once again life as it used to be, as opposed to life as it had become as a result of the white man.

    Given the treatment they had received at the hands of white men to that date, I don’t think that we can blame circa 1889 Sioux for wishing the white man gone by any Deus ex machina, be it by the contrivance of magic or war.

    That the ghost dance foretold reverses of white man’s dominance was not so much the desired ends of the ghost dance, but rather a necessary means to the desired end of a native race once again enjoying pre-European culture and existence. I doubt if we were in there place we would have wished for anything different than they wished for.

    That having been said, Mark Anthony Rolo is wrong to cite long-past events—such as those which occurred in the 1800′s—as tools to drive race relations in 2005.

  4. Digger Says:

    Great informative post.

    Seems like another case of rewriting history to me.

    A lot of that going on these days.

  5. Cardinal Martini Says:

    The Battle of Wounded Knee: or Look what Evil Whitey did to the Redskins

    In 1889, a Paiute Indian named Jack Wilson decided he was the Messiah and created a new movement called the Ghost Dance Religion. It was based on hating the White Man.** Several of the early converts were from the Sioux…

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Subscribe without commenting

 

Powered by WordPress. Stock photography by Matthew J. Stinson. Design by OFJ.