damnum absque injuria

May 28, 2007

Wayne Newton, Terrorist

Filed under:   by Xrlq @ 2:30 pm

Via Patterico, it looks like someone owes Annie Jacobsen and Wayne Newton an apology.

UPDATE: Far from apologizing, Snopes has dug their heels even deeper:

In May 2007, the DHS released to the public its March 2006 review of the “Handling of Suspicious Passengers Aboard Northwest Flight 327,” which included the following statement from the TSA (Transportation Security Administration):

“Overall, a key element when considering the response to this incident should be noted, which is that the 13 Syrian musicians were not terrorists and that the law enforcement assessments made by the FAMS and FBI on June 29, 2004 were appropriate. The decision not to contact the HSOC was decided only after the FAMS and FBI leadership jointly determined that the subjects could be cleared. The reported suspicious activity was determined to be unfounded, and not a terrorist threat …”

Um… yeah, the DHS report did indeed include that line, but only in the sense that every good fisking “includes” the material being fisked. Here’s how it actually appears in the document in question, in context (scroll down to p. 19):

Other Comments
TSA noted in comments that it disagreed with our report language that there was a lack of coordinated action between the FAMS and FBI. Our audit identified examples where the Department’s investigators were interviewing individuals and taking other investigative actions without the direction or knowledge of the FBI. Because we also found activities where the FBI and the Department were clearly coordinated, we revised the report language to say the investigations were “sometimes” uncoordinated.

TSA also commented that it believed a referral of the suspicious activity that occurred on Flight 327 did not merit referral to the HSOC. TSA’s comments note, “The decision not to contact the HSOC was decided only after the FAMS and FBI leadership jointly determined that the subjects could be cleared. The reported suspicious activity was determined to be unfounded, and not a terrorist threat and therefore did not merit an HSOC referral.” We believe the HSOC clearly signaled a referral was merited by logging the Flight 327 matter into its database on July 26, 2004, following a July 22, 2005 Washington Times article, and an inquiry from the White House Homeland Security Council.

Yeah, that sounds like a ringing endorsement of TSA’s position, doesn’t it?

Allah has more.

4 Responses to “Wayne Newton, Terrorist”

  1. Pablo Says:

    Hey, you weren’t supposed to read that far into the report! ;-)

  2. SayUncle » Snopes Says:

    [...] I guess Snopes needs its own, err, snopes. [...]

  3. DWPittelli Says:

    But the cop said, “I didn’t file a report because I determined that a report wasn’t necessary.”

    Obviously that’s a fact that a defendant might use in arguing that he has been exonerated, but not one the cop could use to exonerate himself from the charge of screwing up by not filing a report. It is practically a tautology, and amounts merely to a claim that he did not fail to act out of malicious or corrupt motives (i.e., that the cop is not a terrorist).

  4. Papertiger Says:

    I’m gonna have to rethink the whole “Bigfoot” thing now.
    Might be possible.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Subscribe without commenting

 

Powered by WordPress. Stock photography by Matthew J. Stinson. Design by OFJ.